Monday, May 24, 2010

I did not find Amana somewhere I belong.

Somewhere to Belong - By Judith Miller

I'm sorry. I hate writing bad reviews about books. I LOVE reading, and am so thankful to be part of the review board for Bethany House Publishers. It lets me receive books for free.

But this book just hit a raw nerve with me. I grew up in a cult like religion, and the unbending and unwritten rules in this book just got under my skin. They reminded me of how no one can measure up under those circumstances.

I didn't like the fact that Berta was labeled "rebellious". When I had to abide by unbending rules with no grace involved, I was considered rebellious too. :( And the fact that Johanna was punished because of the supposed wrongdoings of Berta made me feel angry too.

I was expecting a book more along the lines of Beverly Lewis's Amish books, which I adore! But this book is nothing like them, in my opinion.

All in all, I won't be reading any more of the books in this series, and probably won't read another book by Judith Miller.

1 comment:

  1. I understand the cult like religion.... but often there is a reason for it. Sorry it pushed your buttons. There is also the abuse of grace.....

    I'm sorry you were labeled!
    Your review makes me want to read it!

    ReplyDelete